ScoutIndex Rating · v1

2005 ratings — QB

Position-relative, 20–99, from nflverse/nflfastR data. How it's computed →

#	Rating	Player	Pos	Tm	Pct
1	96.5	Peyton Manning	QB	IND	100
2	87.2	Tom Brady	QB	NE	99
3	86.2	Carson Palmer	QB	CIN	98
4	84.8	Matt Hasselbeck	QB	SEA	96
5	80.3	Trent Green	QB	KC	95
6	80.2	Ben Roethlisberger	QB	PIT	94
7	79.1	Jake Plummer	QB	DEN	93
8	77.1	Drew Brees	QB	LAC	91
9	72.6	Marc Bulger	QB	LAR	89
10	70.9	Byron Leftwich	QB	JAX	88
11	70.6	Eli Manning	QB	NYG	86
12	70.4	Jake Delhomme	QB	CAR	85
13	70.3	Kurt Warner	QB	ARI	84
14	69.3	Mark Brunell	QB	WAS	83
15	69.1	Drew Bledsoe	QB	DAL	82
16	66	Kerry Collins	QB	LV	80
17	65.6	Donovan McNabb	QB	PHI	78
18	65.6	Mike Vick	QB	ATL	79
19	64.4	Brad Johnson	QB	MIN	77
20	64.2	Steve McNair	QB	TEN	75
21	63	Aaron Brooks	QB	NO	70
22	59.1	Gus Frerotte	QB	MIA	52
23	58.7	Brett Favre	QB	GB	49
24	58.5	Kelly Holcomb	QB	BUF	47
25	58	Chris Simms	QB	TB	44
26	57	Josh McCown	QB	ARI	43
27	55	Anthony Wright	QB	BAL	32
28	55	Kyle Boller	QB	BAL	31
29	54.7	David Carr	QB	HOU	30
30	52.3	Brooks Bollinger	QB	NYJ	21
31	51.8	Trent Dilfer	QB	CLE	20
32	50.3	Joey Harrington	QB	DET	15
33	46.9	J.P. Losman	QB	BUF	7
34	44.9	Mike McMahon	QB	PHI	5
35	37.9	Kyle Orton	QB	CHI	3